Showing posts with label Trade or Aid?. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Trade or Aid?. Show all posts

Friday, May 20, 2011

Lagarde? Warum eigentlich? (amv)

Kurzer Kommentar von Heike Göbel (FAZ.NET) über die hoch gehandelte Nachfolgekandidatin von DSK. Highlight:
Warum eigentlich Lagarde? [...] Der Ministerin mit dem ausgeprägten Hang zum Interventionismus verdankt Deutschland die krude Empfehlung, seine Exportstärke durch höhere Löhne zu dämpfen, sich quasi der Wettbewerbsfähigkeit durch staatliche Eingriffe in die Lohnpolitik zu berauben. Lagarde steht in der französischen Tradition, im Zweifel für mehr Koordination als für mehr Wettbewerb zu sprechen. Sie ist die Haupt-Advokatin ungebremster Staatshilfe, private Kreditgeber will sie an der Rettung zahlungsunfähiger Euroländer nicht beteiligen.
Besonders erfreulich ist, dass der Antagonismus zwischen 'Koordination' und Wettbewerb gesehen wird. Die Eurozone ist entweder eine Stabilitäts- und Wettbewerbsgemeinschaft, oder aber eine Haftungs- und Transfergemeinschaft. Insofern ist auch der sogenannte 'Pakt für Wettbewerbsfähigkeit' nichts anderes als ein Beispiel für Orwellschen Newspeak. Aber auch hier ist auf FAZ.NET Verlass.

Wednesday, June 10, 2009

Let them fail … God damn it! (amv)

This post is about some of the most elementary principles of economic theory, nothing really new and well known to economists since … mmmh …. say 1776, the year Adam Smith’s Wealth of Nations was published and the Declaration of Independence signed in the New World. You do not need to have a Ph.D. in economics or be a rocket scientist in any respect to understand the following outline. What motivates this post, however, is the lack of sound economic reasoning in most newspaper articles and in television news.

This morning (I am writing this around midnight, so it was rather yesterday morning), watching the Morgenmagazin, I was shocked by a lady (still) working for Karstadt and terribly afraid to lose her job. She even mentioned that her little daughter - who heard some rumors about mummy’s endangered job – confronted her with the situation … and mom openly concedes that this made her brake down in tears. She seemed absolutely devastated: ‘For such an such years I made a great job here and nevertheless my standard of living is threatened. How can this be? I did what I was supposed to do. Bla bla bla. I am not guilty - it’s someone elses fault, not mine. bla bla, thus: Mr./Mrs. Taxpayer, come and bail me out! Save my job!' Politics, especially the German social democrats under the lead of Mr. ‘I-have-no-clue-but-I-want-to-win–elections Steinmeier, attempts to ‘save every job, if possible’ and considers to help all those many poor fellows out there, who produce a marginal value product below their incomes (which is exactly the rule for outright populists and demagogues such as Steinmeier).

To a cold-hearted economist, however, the answer is straightforward: let all those companies go bankrupt that cannot generate revenues to balance their costs. Making losses is a clear signal: the resources employed in the provision of all the goods and services in question, from Opel cars to Karstadt stores, are more precious in other lines of production. Let the market take care of it: just imagine we would have frozen the structure of production 50 years ago, with the same line of reasoning put forward today: ‘but all those innocent people!’ The problem is: this is no question of guilt! And if someone is guilty than the consumers are, who arrogate themselves to buy something else. Honestly, do you have an Opel? Do you purchase your stuff at Karstadt? And why not! We work for our income, that is, also we have to supply our labor force and hope that someone can profit by maximizing someone else’s utility. Max U by making profit! It is the simultaneous occurrence of a variety of different people with different preference scales, a multitude of alternative productive opportunities and technological knowledge, and a complex system of highly differentiated resource endowments that generate profit and loss signals which guide resources to their most productive uses (thus defined).

Indeed, our mommy and the management of Karstadt are the true villains of this plot: they want the monopoly of power the give them our incomes which we obviously prefer to spend on someone else, on other mum’s and their kids! What rights do they have? What about all those mom’s and dad’s that would earn these incomes instead? Long, long time ago, Frederik Bastiat, a French journalist of the highest rank, distinguished between ‘what is seen and what is unseen’. What is seen are the jobs lost today. These jobs get public attention. What remains unseen are the jobs that could be created, if policy would not have intervened. These remain in the dark and nobody cares. The tyranny of the status quo!

The good news: a market economy is not a zero-sum game, so that every winner is evidence of someone losing. Just look at the long-run time series of per capita incomes … but compare those of market systems with those in which the tribe mentality of the masses is allowed to meddle with institutions and to destroy the market mechanism. So don’t get fooled by some pseudo-romantic ideas about social justice. In economic history many loosing industries claimed that they are too important and to profitable to leave the stage. If they were, why did they need the monopoly of power, coercing the general public to finance their employees way of life? In all these cases they sold their special interests as a matter of general welfare. This is no question of social justice – whatever this may be. So let them fail … God damn it!

Monday, November 17, 2008

Gary Becker in defence of bankruptcy (amv)

The daily dose of truth:

The big three American auto producers General Motors, Ford, and Chrysler, are in terrible financial shape. They have asked the government for a bailout, and the Democratic leadership in Congress is eager to give them one. The United Auto Workers union was a strong supporter of President-elect Obama and of Democratic candidates.

These companies have lost tens of billions of dollars during the past few years, and they will shortly run out of cash. GM's shares have lost almost all their value, and Ford has not done much better. Cerberus Capital, a private equity company, owns Chrysler, and it has lost most of what it invested in the company. For this reason Cerberus is trying get out of the automobile manufacturing business. All three companies were heavily into producing trucks and SUV's when the sharp run up in gas prices induced consumers to shift away from these gas-guzzlers and toward smaller and more fuel-efficient cars. Moreover, what money GM had been making came mainly not from car production but from its automobile credit business, (GMAC). This company would borrow from banks to lend to consumers who needed help in financing their GM car purchases. The financial crisis has dried up the money available to auto financing companies, and hence eliminated the major source of their profits.

If GM is not bailed out, the company claims it will be forced into bankruptcy within a few months, and Ford's situation is only slightly better. GM is blitzing Congress, President Bush, and President -elect Obama with pleas for a bailout, followed by a warning that bankruptcy will also hurt auto suppliers throughout the nation that depend on GM's business. GM is also claiming that bankruptcy will put major financial pressure on the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corp, the federal agency that insures benefits to retirees in the auto industry as well as to million of other workers.

Nevertheless, I believe bankruptcy is better than a bailout for American consumers and taxpayers. The main problem with American auto companies is that during the good times of the 1970s, 1980s and 1990s, they made overly generous settlements with the United Auto workers (UAW) on wages, pensions, and health benefits. Only a couple of years ago, GM was paying $5 billion per year in health benefits to retirees and current employees because their plans had wide health coverage with minimal co-payments and deductibility on health claims by present and retired employees. In those days, the UAW was one of the most powerful unions in the US, and it bargained aggressively with the auto manufacturers, carrying out strikes when its demands were not met. When the American auto industry began to face tough competition from Japanese and German carmakers, they were saddled with excessive pay to their workers, and vastly excessive pensions and health benefits to their current and retired workers.

It is not that cars cannot be produced profitably with American workers: the American plants of Toyota and other Japanese companies, and of German auto manufacturers, have been profitable for many years. The foreign companies have achieved this mainly by setting up their factories in Southern and border states where they could avoid the UAW, and thereby introduce efficient methods of production. Their workers have been paid well but not excessively, and these companies have kept their pension and health obligations under control while still maintaining good morale among their employees. In recent years GM and the other American manufacturers have chipped away at their generous fringe benefits, but their health and retirement benefits still considerably exceed those received by American auto workers employed by foreign companies. As a result of lower costs, better management, and less hindrance from work rules imposed by the UAW, about 1/3 of all cars produced in the US now come from foreign owned plants.

Bankruptcy would help GM and Ford become more competitive by abrogating significant parts of their labor contracts with the UAW. One of the greatest needs would be sizable reduction in their health costs through sharp increases in the deductibility and co-payments, and a reduced coverage of medical procedures. Bankruptcy should also help bring the wage rates of GM and Ford in line with those of foreign producers in the US. Some of their pension liabilities may be shifted onto the Pension Benefit Guarantee Corp, but even that would be preferable to an overall bailout.

A good analogy is what happened to United Airlines. By entering bankruptcy it was able to reduce its inflated cost structure by breaking contracts it had with the pilots union and other employee unions. It exited bankruptcy a slimmer and more efficient airline. Whether it is able to compete effectively in the long run is still not certain, but it is in much better shape to compete than before it entered bankruptcy.

Bankruptcy may also force out the current management of GM and Ford. I do not know for certain whether they have competent management- GM surely did not have top management for much of its recent history. I do believe, however, that when a coach of a team loses a few games, he might legitimately explain that by injuries, bad luck, or even bad officiating. These excuses become lame when he consistently loses many games, and the correct and common practice is then to fire the coach. The same considerations apply to top management. When a company consistently does badly while some of its competitors (like Toyota) are doing well, its time to fire the management team, and see if another team can do better.

Is GM "too big" to fail? I do not believe the company is too big to go into a reorganization-which is what bankruptcy would involve. Such reorganization would abrogate its untenable labor contracts, and give it a chance to survive in long run. A bailout, by contrast, would simply postpone the needed reforms in these labor contracts, the business model of GM, and its management.

Source: The Becker-Posner Blog

Monday, November 3, 2008

Comparative advantages (amv)

Here is one of the best statements of the principle of comparative advantages. It is concise and applied not only to international trade but to exchange as such. We owe it to Steven Horwitz:

“It is through exchange that difference becomes a blessing, not a curse.” So wrote Jonathan Sacks, the Chief Rabbi of Great Britain. In one concise and beautiful sentence, Sacks captured the essence of one of the most fundamental concepts in economics: the idea of comparative advantage and the role it plays in promoting human cooperation through specialization, the division of labor, and exchange.

The concept of comparative advantage was first conceived in the context of international trade, as David Ricardo, writing at the start of the 19th century, recognized that nations were better off when they specialized in the things they could do best and then traded the surplus above what they consumed themselves with other countries specializing in producing what they were relatively best at. Nations that tried to be self-sufficient would impoverish their citizens by trying to produce goods for themselves at a higher relative cost than could their trading partners. Instead, they could enrich their citizens by allowing them to trade for what they couldn’t produce efficiently themselves.

What was key to Ricardo’s insight was that a country could actually be better than a trading partner at producing both, for example, cotton and wine, but that it still made sense for them to specialize in the one of the two they were better at in comparison to that trading partner. That is where the “comparative” in comparative advantage comes from: by specializing in the one of the two that it is comparatively better at, each country can consume what it wishes and trade the surplus for the other country’s surplus. Specialization and exchange enables countries to consume more than they would be able to if each tried to do both themselves. The same logic applies when there are a larger number of traders. Free trade between nations enhances the well-being of all who trade.

Ricardo’s insight, however, goes far beyond international trade. We can apply to the same logic to the ways in which individuals specialize in particular productive activities and then trade their surpluses for other goods. I specialize in producing “economic education services.” I don’t need many of them myself, so I sell just about all of them to St. Lawrence University, who in turn pays me. I take that money and buy groceries, housing, clothing, a car payment, etc. with the proceeds. Each person or organization I buy from has themselves specialized by their comparative advantage and is trading their surplus with me. This process of specialization by comparative advantage, and the resulting division of labor and exchange activity, is the way in which free trade among individuals, households, and firms turns into benefits for all. What works at the level of nations, works at the level of individuals and vice versa. And as with nations, markets allow everyone who can produce positive value to find their comparative advantage and in so doing contribute to the betterment of all.

Notice an interesting aspect of the analogy between nations and individuals: when a country imports more than it exports with another country, we label that a “trade deficit” and it usually worries us. However, when I “import” more food from my local grocery store than I export in the form of “economic education services” that it buys from me (I don’t stand in the produce section giving economics lectures, after all), no one gets panicky about my “trade deficit” with the grocer. In fact, such “deficits” (including St. Lawrence’s “trade deficit” with me) are simply another label for the specialization and exchange process that makes it possible for me to obtain consumption items that are much too costly to produce myself. It is interesting to ask why we recognize the value of such specialization by individuals, but are often quick to condemn it when it involves nations.

Production by comparative advantage also enhances the peacefulness of human interactions. When we specialize and trade, we become interdependent. I am dependent upon the specialization of my grocer to get my food. Students rely on my specialization as a professor to learn economics. This form of social cooperation reduces the incentive for us to harm our trading partners, as harming those we depend upon harms us as well. Once again, what is true of individuals is also true of nations: countries that engage in free trade with each other are much less likely to go to war. Expanding the degree of international specialization through free trade is also a path to increased global peace.

And it is through this process of specialization and exchange that “difference becomes a blessing, not a curse.” It is fashionable these days to extoll the virtues of diversity. Most of the time, those discussions have little to do with economics. That is unfortunate, because once one understands the concept of comparative advantage, one can see how economics helps us to reveal perhaps the most important benefit of diversity: when people are free to produce by comparative advantage and then trade what they produce, human diversity becomes a source of both increased material well-being and expanded peaceful human cooperation. The more freedom we give to people to engage in the market process, the more that diversity and difference really do become humanity’s blessing and not its curse.

Thursday, February 7, 2008

Trade or aid? (amv)

Bill Gates is all-famous, not only for being the founder of Microsoft and hence for becoming one among the wealthiest men on this planet, but more recently for his philanthropy, for his fight against poverty, especially in Africa. Now, William Easterly has published a book in 2006 on the success of foreign aid. The title speaks for itself: The White Man's Burden: Why the West's Efforts to Aid the Rest Have Done So Much Ill and So Little Good. It come as no surprise that Mr. Gates cannot agree with Easterly's conclusion that the masses are lifted from poverty not by benevolence but by profit-seeking activity. To say it with Adam Smith:
“It is not the benevolence of the butcher, the brewer, or the baker, that we expect our dinner, but from their regard to their own interest. We address ourselves, not to their humanity but to their self-love, and never talk to them of our necessities but of their advantages.”
This was written in 1776 (in the same year the Declaration of Independence was signed. Both shared a common intellectual heritage) and came to be known under the heading "The Invisible Hand." Mr. Gates, a truly great entrepreneur who has done more for mankind by producing software than by donating the fruits of his efforts, disagrees with Easterly on the following:

The market may serve those who can pay, but bluntly ignores those who cannot afford to do so, those who are in most desperate need for the goods and services produced. This statement is true as far as it goes. Yet, it does not go so far. Demand is, of course, a prerequisite for the existence of economic value giving capitalism meaning and purpose. Demand is an outgrowth and determinant of scarcity and scarcity is what economic activity is all about. And demand has to be dressed in monetary outlays, otherwise the system is blind to it and ignores the needs expressed. And since Africa is poor, that is, since it cannot signal demand by the ability to spend, the world market directs little attention to the people suffering most from poverty.

However, all demand depends upon supply! Not only Africans but all of us have to engage in productive activities to satisfy our ends, that is, we have to serve others by adding our one endowments to the stream of goods and services flowing towards the satisfaction of other consumers. Demand is not the restriction, but supply. For capitalism did not grew strong by mere spending out of nothing, but by the interaction of demand and supply, by demand made possible by supply. Production is the essence of capitalism and the source of our riches, although demand gives meaning and direction to the entire process. In other words: Africans are not poor because capitalism simply ignores them, but because you generally cannot take out of the system without engaging yourself and therewith contributing to others within the system (gifts depend on someone others contribution; this is also true for theft and taxes). Your income increases the better your abilities are in serving others better and cheaper. Your abilities, however, depend on the width and the depth of the capital stock you can be attached with.

If you want to take measures against AIDS or other diseases (as done also by Prof. Sachs) that's fine, as long as you do not believe that it will make a significant contribution to the poor's living. But if you want to make a real change, you have to eliminate all restrictions to the accumulation of capital by the process of saving and investment (including foreign savings and investments). Once capital is free, Mr Gates will see that capitalism is not the enemy of the masses but their closest ally. It is capitalism to which we owe mass production and thus the supply of various goods affordable to the poorest. After all, even low-income groups in capitalist countries have access and make use of Windows! But let Mr. Easterly have the final word. In his reply to Mr. Gates he writes:

"Profit-motivated capitalism, on the other hand, has done wonders for poor workers. Self-interested capitalist factory owners buy machines that increase production, and thus profits. Capitalists search for technological breakthroughs that make it possible to get more output for the same amount of input. Working with more machinery and better technology, workers produce more output per hour. In a competitive labor market, the demand for these more productive workers increases, driving up their wages. The steady increase in wages for unskilled labor lifts the workers out of poverty.

The number of poor people who can't afford food for their children is a lot smaller than it used to be -- thanks to capitalism. Capitalism didn't create malnutrition, it reduced it. The globalization of capitalism from 1950 to the present has increased annual average income in the world to $7,000 from $2,000. Contrary to popular legend, poor countries grew at about the same rate as the rich ones. This growth gave us the greatest mass exit from poverty in world history.

The parts of the world that are still poor are suffering from too little capitalism. Foreign direct investment in Africa today, although rising, amounts to only 1% of global flows. That's because the environment for private business in Africa is still hostile. There are some industry and country success stories in Africa, but not enough.

[...] Sure, let those who have become rich under capitalism try to do good things for those who are still poor, as Mr. Gates has admirably chosen to do. But a New-Age blend of market incentives and feel-good recognition will not end poverty. History has shown that profit-motivated capitalism is still the best hope for the poor."
Nature is a niggard! It is capitalism which shifts the burden of scarcity!